Poll positions: Why teams shuffle

More news about: Franklin | Mount Union
Always keep in mind not just the rank, but number of votes. UHMB was just one vote ahead of Linfield in the preseason. 

Over the years, Pat Coleman and I, and often the other 23 D3football.com top 25 voters, have come to believe in some poll principles.

The laziest kind of poll rewards everyone who wins regardless of level of competition or circumstances of the results, and dings everyone who loses. We've never thought a poll like that serves the D-III community, so even though we still only influence 2/25ths of the voting, we're glad to have assembled a panel that values nuance. Still, that doesn't stop our colleagues and most loyal fans from voicing their disappointment over the top 25s that come out each week.

Personally, I don't think a top 25 can ever be perfect, but the more data you have to work with, the more accurate it can be. More data sometimes leads to conflicting data, but it's still better than having only preseason educated guesses to work with. Or is it? Our Stagg Bowl broadcast colleague Frank Rossi loves to argue. On Twitter, I made the apparently absurd suggestion that it was better to have an actual result to work with, and it was on.

Frank in this case has a valid point, and I actually agree with him to an extent. Let's present both sides of the argument and let you decide.

I've never been a fan of a poll that starts out ranking teams for a current year based solely on where they finished the previous year, and using that information to heavily influence the current year.

I don't have a problem working with the only data available in the preseason, but that shouldn't just be order of 2012 finish. It should look heavily at returning starters, quality of those starters, and maybe schedule or other 2013 factors. Now with a 2013 game in the books for most of the teams in the top 25, it's much easier to re-order.

I can't stand a poll that simply rewards everyone who wins, as though everyone played the same level of opponent under the same circumstances. I don't believe in dropping every team about five spots every time they lose either. A team can go entirely out of the poll in a week not because that one loss caused them to drop 15 spots, but because that information, coupled with everything else we know, suddenly paints a picture.

Each week is an opportunity to re-evaluate everything you know. It's not a magnetic pegboard where you just rearrrange a team or two. If the team you thought was going to win the WIAC suddenly looks like the third best team in the WIAC, then maybe you re-order the WIAC teams in your top 25. Or maybe you downgrade the conference as a whole.

A team can go entirely out of the poll in a week not because that one loss caused them to drop 15 spots, but because that information, coupled with everything else we know, suddenly paints a picture.

To me, the last thing you want to do is stay too married to what you thought before. Still, the framework for my vote each week is the vote I cast last week. It helps me remember who I thought highly of, and directs me where to look, so I don't forget anyone and I examine everyone's results closely. The ability to admit I might have been wrong in previous weeks is the key to being as close to correct as possible this week.

So when Pat and I each suggested on Twitter that we were doing our polls from scratch, it's not as if all 25 spots were completely up for grabs. Each of the the teams at the top of my ballot -- Linfield, St. Thomas, Wesley, Mount Union and Mary Hardin-Baylor -- were very impressive, with the exception of the Wildcats, who had yet to play. I didn't have a reason to downgrade anyone, so I stuck with what I had, which meant no one moved up either. I felt good that everyone at the top of my poll impressed. I moved other teams around wildly -- UW-Whitewater fell hard but remained top 20, while Delaware Valley, Willamette and St. John Fisher joined my ranks. I don't think that's a case of putting too much emphasis on Week 1.

A voter should be balancing what we know to date with the intent of being accurate as of now with the idea that some things that he expects are true will also be reflected. To me, ignoring the Week 1 results is placing too much emphasis on the unknown -- the preseason order of teams -- or the mostly irrelevant -- last year's finishes. Obviously we need some historical baseline to formulate an opinion at all. Otherwise the top 25 would just be whichever of the 244 teams had the highest margin of victory in Week 1, or something silly like that. Which brings me to these tweets:

That's sort of an odd tack to take for Lousiana College fans, whose whole argument last season was that their only losses were to UMHB and Wesley, two top-10 teams. LC as much as anyone benefited from respect given to their aggressive scheduling, and gained poll respect despite not winning. When UMHB hosts LC on Oct. 19, those same Wildcat fans may have flipped their argument and begin asking for credit for losing respectably to one of the nation's elite teams.

Frankly, Franklin wasn't a team that most voters thought could almost beat Mount Union prior to Week 1. When Week 1 tells you the Grizzlies are that team, then you have two options: Pay them respect for being better than you thought, or ding Mount Union for being worse. Players are coached to have a win-or-nothing mentality sometimes. But when you step outside that locker room, if you believe all wins are created equal, I'm sure I could find you some D-III polls that you'd be more comfortable with. In the end, these tweets are the most wise:


Adam Turer

Adam Turer graduated in 2006 from Washington and Lee University, where he was a two-year starter at free safety. He lives in Cincinnati and covers area high school sports in addition to his full-time job as an attorney. Adam has contributed to D3football.com since 2007 and is in his second season writing Around the Nation after spending four seasons writing Around the Mid-Atlantic.

2014-2015 columnist: Ryan Tipps.
2001-2013 columnist: Keith McMillan.

Previous Columns

December 22, 2017
2017 Year in Review
This was a bittersweet year, Adam Turer writes. Despite players who didn't finish the season, to an...
November 16, 2017
Playoff picks, surprises and disappointments
Who are the teams that will surprise in this year's playoffs? Who will be the disappointments? And...
November 12, 2017
Playing up to expectations
Our projections and predictions were impressive. Let's take a look back at the teams we thought...
November 9, 2017
End of a long road
Barry Streeter ends his 39-year head-coaching career with his final game on Saturday, and Regis...
November 5, 2017
Going out on a high note
Dozens of seniors played their final college football game yesterday. Many had to balance the sting...
November 2, 2017
Cru's success is infectious
Mary Hardin-Baylor's 2016 national title may well have lit a fire under the rest of the Crusaders'...
October 29, 2017
Built for the stretch run
Some programs had backloaded schedules this year. These final few weeks are their time to prove...
October 26, 2017
Surviving the quick change
There were quite a few late-season coaching changes, and it meant an end to one program as well as a...
October 22, 2017
Let's have a breakdown together
Three games on Saturday provided clarity in the playoff picture. There is still much to be decided...
October 19, 2017
No longer beasts, East trying to break back through
No East Region team has finished the season in Salem since 1999, and it has been 10 years since an...
October 15, 2017
Occidental not giving up yet
The Tigers cancelled yet another home game, this time on homecoming weekend. Emotions are running...
October 12, 2017
Bruins' long road to respect
Seven-plus years of planning, four-plus years of practice and three-plus years of competition have...
October 8, 2017
Picks and polls
Interceptions won some games and clinched others across Division III this weekend. Adam Turer looks...
October 5, 2017
Re-ranking the conferences in 2017
When conference memberships shift as much as they have this year, ranking the conferences becomes an...
October 1, 2017
Through the eyes of the quarterback
What is it like to pass for over 500 yards in a game, or over 1,400 yards through four games? Few...
September 28, 2017
Hot starts create unlikely unbeatens
As we head into the final weekend of the season’s first month, 39 teams sit at either 3-0 or...
September 24, 2017
An emotional week
Loss, scandal, history, and catharsis. This week had everything. From Wooster honoring their...
September 21, 2017
Rivalry showdown takes center field
Don't let the unique location or record-breaking attendance numbers distract you. The Tommie-Johnnie...
September 17, 2017
Feeding the beasts
Several teams remained undefeated by following a familiar formula: get the ball in your best...
September 14, 2017
Back from hiatus
Three former All-Region players spent 2016 on the sidelines. One was actually on the sidelines after...
September 10, 2017
How to pull off an upset
It takes aggression. Fourth downs, fake punts, and two-point conversions all factored into the...
September 7, 2017
Digging in for Duke
Muhlenberg head coach Mike Donnelly has been forced to the sidelines this year as he fights acute...
September 3, 2017
Remembering how to win again
Week One did not disappoint. Snap Judgments returns, getting you caught up on the Top 25 upsets,...
August 31, 2017
This season signifies one last shot at Salem
If you've never been to Salem for the Stagg Bowl, 2017 will be your last chance, at least for a...
December 20, 2016
Year in review: The year everything changed
We had a brand-new Division III national champion for the first time since 2007. Mount Union lost a...
November 17, 2016
Playoff picks, surprises, disappointments
Around the Nation has assembled a team of prognosticators for an annual look at who might surprise...
November 13, 2016
Snap Judgments: Hellos and goodbyes
Today is going to be bittersweet for many. We take a look at the teams that announced their arrival...
November 10, 2016
Out of the darkness, light
Sometimes, things don’t go your way. Sometimes, your highest expectations are crushed by...
 • More Division III football news releases

Other Columnists