On this day, they were all big games

A familiar sight: Wabash with the Monon Bell. But that only makes them one of 11 playoff-eligible at-large candidates with one loss, and there are just five at-large bids and eight bids that aren't automatic.
Wabash athletics photo by Howard Hewitt

If it seemed like everybody in Division III thought their Week 11 game was a big one, that's because, depending on perspective, every game was.

The games with playoff bids and conference titles on the line we all knew about. The oldest and most heated rivalries get talked about regardless of the quality of the participants. But even in the brand-new rivalries, or the lukewarm ones, or the games between sub-.500 teams, much was at stake. Any game where a senior took the field for the final team in his career, as his team played for the final time in the 2013 was big to that player, plus his teammates, fans and family.

"Big" depends on perspective, and who can judge us for being a little self-absorbed when something we've enjoyed so much, whether for a career or just a fall full of Saturday's, is winding to its end.

Yet our D-III experience is sometimes so self absorbed, we're unaware that there are 29 conferences, 244 teams and in the neighborhood of 20,000 players. Within that group are more outstanding accomplishments than most of us can count. So while it doesn't make an accomplishment any less special -- especially from a particular perspective -- it might mean that something your team did this Saturday or this season was repeated several times across the country. And it sometimes is tough to take a step back to see the bigger picture and realize it.

Which is a long way of me introducing these facts. There are 32 playoff spots, 24 filled by automatic qualifiers. Three go to teams that weren't in AQ conferences, and the other five are awarded at large.

Here are the 14 teams that finished the season with one loss, but aren't headed to the playoffs as one of the 24 conference's AQs:

Greenville, 9-1
Framingham State, 9-1
Illinois Wesleyan, 9-1
John Carroll, 9-1
Millsaps, 9-1
Pacific Lutheran, 8-1
Thomas More, 9-1
UW-Platteville, 9-1
Wabash, 9-1
Chapman, 8-1
Texas Lutheran, 8-1
Amherst, 7-1
Middlebury, 7-1
Wesleyan, 7-1

Here are 18 more teams that finished with two losses:
Christopher Newport, 8-2
Concordia-Moorhead, 8-2
Eureka, 8-2
Illinois College, 8-2
Heidelberg, 8-2
Lake Forest, 8-2
Methodist, 8-2
Muhlenberg, 8-2
Rhodes, 8-2
St. John Fisher, 8-2
St. Thomas, 8-2
Southern Virginia, 8-2
UW-Oshkosh, 8-2
Washington U., 8-2
Wesley, 8-2
Wheaton, 8-2
Western Connecticut, 7-2
Willamette, 7-2

Another 27 teams finished 7-3, and MIT finished 6-3.

From this (although not all the above teams are playoff eligible), the selection committee must add only eight teams to the field of 32 that didn't qualify by winning a conference.

So when the official @d3football twitter feed or I stomp on your dreams of dancing one more week as an at-large playoff invitee, please don't take it personally. There's just not much room at the inn for those who aren't conference champions. That's how the AQ system works.

D-III football is one giant animal. Even with 32 teams in the playoffs, some pretty darn good ones are going to get left out. Say, anybody ever proposed a D-III NIT? Last year's Stagg Bowl runner up St. Thomas would be a pretty good No. 1 seed.

Week 11's snap judgments
We get so caught up in the playoff talk that those who aren't in the mix might have their accomplishments overlooked. Here are some things I noticed in Week 11 (and then we'll get back to playoff talk):

• Austin is a program so far off the radar that if you Google "Austin football," it returns results about University of Texas (which is in Austin). On Saturday, the Kangaroos beat Trinity for the first time since 1993, and it was a stomping. (Or maybe a hopping? Eh, never mind). The Tigers managed only 22 yards rushing, and Austin finished 5-5 after an 0-4 start. I love when a team doesn't give up.

• Speaking of which, only Wesley had played a tougher schedule this season than Alma. But the Scots, who lost a couple heartbreakers along the way, go into the offseason with smiles on their faces after beating Trine, 31-13. As a reminder, here's the strength of schedule stats.

• Still speaking of which, Misericordia got the first win in program history, although it was somewhat expected. After 19 losses in a row, including one by a point earlier this season against King's, the Cougars scored a 63-40 win over FDU-Florham, which lost all nine MAC games this season after starting with a win against TCNJ.

• My favorite thing about Cartel Brooks breaking Octavias McKoy's all-division rushing record of 455 yards, set in October? Neither back's 400-plus game was a one-time fluke. The top four single-game rushing performances this season:
Brooks, 465, Week 11
McKoy, 455, Week 8
McKoy, 372, Week 6
Brooks, 337, Week 7

• Albion/Hope and Hampden-Sydney/Randolph-Macon put forth dramatic finishes worthy of winner-take-all games, and John Carroll/Mount Union wasn't bad either. The lone dud among the four AQ-on-the-line games? Endicott's 24-0 win over Salve Regina, in which Drew Frenette threw three third-quarter touchdown passes, and the Seahawks couldn't get anything going despite gaining 325 total yards and only having two turnovers.

• The Dutchman's Shoes game was decided by an RPI touchdown in the final three minutes. With a 41-yard touchdown pass with 1:08 left, Cortland State sent Ithaca into the playoffs on a losing note, winning 28-24. Hampden-Sydney stopped Randolph-Macon on a one and a half-yard two-point conversion attempt to preserve a 28-26 win. Wabash, Monmouth and Thomas More rolled, sure, but it was a pretty decent year for the big D-III rivalry games.

• John Carroll gave up 42 to Mount Union and still finished the season allowing only 75 points in 10 games. Let that sink in a second. Monster defense UW-Whitewater allowed 80 in 10 games, Linfield 99 in nine and Amherst 94 in eight. And that's it for your under-100 club. The Blue Streaks' 7.5 points per game is silly good, since the national average per team per game going into Week 11 was 26.66 points per game. The ASC had a comical 34.29 average, while the UAA, at 19.29, edged the NESCAC for most defensively inclined conference.

• Hat tip to Pacific, for finishing 7-3 in its fourth year, including pushing national No. 2 to the brink in a 28-22 loss.

• Mount Ida scored in the first five minutes and its D held the rest of the way in a 6-0 win against Husson. Macalaster scored in the first eight minutes and its D held the rest of the way in a 7-0 win over Hamline.

• Week 11 is always full of surprises, and this year it featured St. Norbert losing, 31-3, but backing into a playoff spot when Illinois College also lost about an hour later, 23-21 to Carroll. Other teams going into the postseason coming off a loss: Maryville, (45-38 to Huntingdon), Ithaca (28-24 to Cortland State), Lebanon Valley (40-25 to Albright), Gallaudet (7-6 to SUNY-Maritime) and perhaps Millsaps (49-30 to Rhodes). You can expect all of these teams to be on the road in Round 1. Probably at home for Round 2, but crazier things have happened.

One last thing ... here are those Pool B and C tables from midweek, adjusted to reflect today's results and SoS numbers. Also, at the behest of longtime friend of the site Ron Boerger, I'll mix the Pool B overflow teams in in Pool C to reflect the reality that they also have a chance to be discussed as at-large teams if not taken among the Pool B three:

The Pool B picture

I'll just post the facts here for you to analyze (Pat's also posting his projections tonight). This is basically so you, the reader, can look at more or less what the committee is going to consider. Even if you don't agree with whichever way they eventually go, you'll understand why.

There are five primary playoff criteria: Record against regional opponents, strength of schedule, in-region head-to-head, results against in-region common opponents, and in-region results against regionally ranked opponents. There are also seven and a half secondary critieria, which really only come into play when a decision isn't clear from the primary.

This list is not in order of how I expect teams to be selected, it's just the data. Also, keep in mind that the committee will have a fresh set of regional rankings, but all we have to go on right now are the ones from Wednesday.

Team/criteria W-L H2H Common opponents
Millsaps 9-1

Lost to Rhodes, 49-30

Miss. Coll. (W 52-19), Trinity (W 27-24);

B-SC (W 28-14); Centre (W 28-27)

Framingham State 8-1   Rowan (L 29-19)
1-1 (Rowan, W.Conn.)
Wesley 8-2

Rowan (L 24-17); B-SC (W 46-12)

0-2 (UMHB, Rowan) .672
Texas Lutheran 8-1  

Miss. Coll. (W 35-32); Trinity (W 42-38)

Washington U. 8-2 Beat Rhodes, 10-7
Centre (W 31-14), Chicago (W 17-7)

0-1 (UW-W)

Rhodes 8-2 Lost to Wash U.; beat Millsaps
Centre (W 35-14), Chicago (W 41-34); B-SC (L 35-34); Entire SAA in common with Millsaps
1-0 (Millsaps)

















Rhodes beating Millsaps really evened the scales in this group, and to be honest, the cross-play between all these teams went from a help to what may be a hindrance -- too much data to work with. Wash. U beat Rhodes, who beat Millsaps, but Millsaps has nine wins to their eight. Was the loss enough to help Texas Lutheran, even with that massive outlier of an SoS?

The Pool C picture

The only losses by a Pool C contenders were in head-to-head games in the OAC and WIAC. John Carroll was 9-0 and remains in the mix with the loss.

Same disclaimer as above; Pay no mind to the order, just the data.

 Team/criteria  W-L  H2h CO  RRO  SOS
John Carroll 9-1  
   1-1  .520
Pacific Lutheran 8-1   UW-EC (W 21-19)
 0-1  .549
Illinois Wesleyan
     2-1  .499
9-1      1-1  .477
Wabash 9-1      0-1  .503
Thomas More
9-1   W&J (L 45-21)
 0-1  .487
St. John Fisher
8-2   W&J (W 42-21)
 2-1  .575
St. Thomas 8-2   UW-EC (W 52-7)  1-2  .504
8-1        .444
Greenville 9-1        .435

















The strength of schedule gap closed between the top contenders after Week 11. I added the two two-loss teams I think could get into the discussion -- Wheaton, Concordia-Moorhead and others were stuck behind too many other teams. Chapman and Greenville are in the chart not because they have a chance at getting selected, but to show you that committees are looking at more than just one-loss records. On the rest of the criteria, everyone else in this chart stacks up better.

SJFC and UST get a help with their common opponents, but I still think John Carroll, Illinois Wesleyan, UW-Platteville and Pacific Lutheran are pretty safe bets. After that, for the fifth spot, you can make a case for Wabash, St. John Fisher or maybe one of the others. You decide.

Adam Turer

Adam Turer graduated in 2006 from Washington and Lee University, where he was a two-year starter at free safety. He lives in Cincinnati and covers area high school sports in addition to his full-time job as an attorney. Adam has contributed to D3football.com since 2007 and is in his second season writing Around the Nation after spending four seasons writing Around the Mid-Atlantic.

2014-2015 columnist: Ryan Tipps.
2001-2013 columnist: Keith McMillan.

Previous Columns

December 22, 2017
2017 Year in Review
This was a bittersweet year, Adam Turer writes. Despite players who didn't finish the season, to an...
November 16, 2017
Playoff picks, surprises and disappointments
Who are the teams that will surprise in this year's playoffs? Who will be the disappointments? And...
November 12, 2017
Playing up to expectations
Our projections and predictions were impressive. Let's take a look back at the teams we thought...
November 9, 2017
End of a long road
Barry Streeter ends his 39-year head-coaching career with his final game on Saturday, and Regis...
November 5, 2017
Going out on a high note
Dozens of seniors played their final college football game yesterday. Many had to balance the sting...
November 2, 2017
Cru's success is infectious
Mary Hardin-Baylor's 2016 national title may well have lit a fire under the rest of the Crusaders'...
October 29, 2017
Built for the stretch run
Some programs had backloaded schedules this year. These final few weeks are their time to prove...
October 26, 2017
Surviving the quick change
There were quite a few late-season coaching changes, and it meant an end to one program as well as a...
October 22, 2017
Let's have a breakdown together
Three games on Saturday provided clarity in the playoff picture. There is still much to be decided...
October 19, 2017
No longer beasts, East trying to break back through
No East Region team has finished the season in Salem since 1999, and it has been 10 years since an...
October 15, 2017
Occidental not giving up yet
The Tigers cancelled yet another home game, this time on homecoming weekend. Emotions are running...
October 12, 2017
Bruins' long road to respect
Seven-plus years of planning, four-plus years of practice and three-plus years of competition have...
October 8, 2017
Picks and polls
Interceptions won some games and clinched others across Division III this weekend. Adam Turer looks...
October 5, 2017
Re-ranking the conferences in 2017
When conference memberships shift as much as they have this year, ranking the conferences becomes an...
October 1, 2017
Through the eyes of the quarterback
What is it like to pass for over 500 yards in a game, or over 1,400 yards through four games? Few...
September 28, 2017
Hot starts create unlikely unbeatens
As we head into the final weekend of the season’s first month, 39 teams sit at either 3-0 or...
September 24, 2017
An emotional week
Loss, scandal, history, and catharsis. This week had everything. From Wooster honoring their...
September 21, 2017
Rivalry showdown takes center field
Don't let the unique location or record-breaking attendance numbers distract you. The Tommie-Johnnie...
September 17, 2017
Feeding the beasts
Several teams remained undefeated by following a familiar formula: get the ball in your best...
September 14, 2017
Back from hiatus
Three former All-Region players spent 2016 on the sidelines. One was actually on the sidelines after...
September 10, 2017
How to pull off an upset
It takes aggression. Fourth downs, fake punts, and two-point conversions all factored into the...
September 7, 2017
Digging in for Duke
Muhlenberg head coach Mike Donnelly has been forced to the sidelines this year as he fights acute...
September 3, 2017
Remembering how to win again
Week One did not disappoint. Snap Judgments returns, getting you caught up on the Top 25 upsets,...
August 31, 2017
This season signifies one last shot at Salem
If you've never been to Salem for the Stagg Bowl, 2017 will be your last chance, at least for a...
December 20, 2016
Year in review: The year everything changed
We had a brand-new Division III national champion for the first time since 2007. Mount Union lost a...
November 17, 2016
Playoff picks, surprises, disappointments
Around the Nation has assembled a team of prognosticators for an annual look at who might surprise...
November 13, 2016
Snap Judgments: Hellos and goodbyes
Today is going to be bittersweet for many. We take a look at the teams that announced their arrival...
November 10, 2016
Out of the darkness, light
Sometimes, things don’t go your way. Sometimes, your highest expectations are crushed by...
 • More Division III football news releases

Other Columnists