Big drama on the small stage

More news about: Gettysburg | Lebanon Valley

Let's think about this scenario: One team jumps out to an impressive lead of three touchdowns, only to see its opponent fiercely battle back by the third quarter with three end zone strikes of their own.

And then grit sets in. Mental toughness becomes just as important a component as physical skill and stamina. Momentum once again shifts. The first team uses big plays to wear down the opposing players. The lead -- and ultimately victory -- again becomes theirs.

If you were tuned into ESPN on Monday night, you saw the drama. And this scenario might sound familiar.

But that's not where I'm going with this.

Because in Annville, Pa., far away from the bright lights of suburban Washington and the glint of television cameras, the drama unfolded between Gettysburg and Lebanon Valley.

When the dust settled, the Bullets were the last standing in a 42-28 matchup against a team that came just one point away from a likely playoff appearance in 2009. Gettysburg, on the other hand, struggled that year through loss after loss to finish 3-7.

"We were looking at it as playing a team that had a really great season last year and had a lot of players returning," said Gettysburg coach Barry Streeter. "I just told [the players] that this is a chance for us to see how much better we can get and where we are as a team."

So where exactly does that leave them? The answer is: in a state of confidence. The team graduated its standout quarterback after last season, but in stepped Kyle Whitmoyer, a tough athlete who is quick on his feet. He was a natural in the role. The junior threw for 114 yards and ran for 130 more, including three touchdowns.

Because Gettysburg has primarily a zone-read offense, Streeter says of Whitmoyer, "He throws the ball well enough for us." Indeed he does, and he's just the kind of mobile quarterback that can help Gettysburg thrive.

But what really perhaps turned the tide on Saturday were the turnovers that Gettysburg forced -- five in all.

Scoring started early and started fast. The Bullets broke out to a 21-0 lead after the first quarter, only to see the Flying Dutchmen score three times over the next 16 minutes.

Streeter knew the kind of battle he had on his hands.

"I figured they weren't going to roll over, that's for sure," he said. "We've been really preaching to our kids about playing it one play at a time and not being overly concerned about what the next play is going to mean or what the score is going to be. So I was just trying to practice what I was preaching."

Gettysburg followed up Lebanon Valley's third score with an 80-yard drive, but more importantly, the game changer came just 43 seconds later when defensive back Tyler Fasanella recovered a fumble and brought it 45 yards into the end zone.

But Streeter said it wasn't until the team put together an 11-play, 54-yard drive midway through the fourth quarter that he could breathe a little easier about the game and where it appeared to be ending up. The drive didn't end in any points, but it ate nearly 6 minutes, 30 seconds off the clock and highlighted his team's determination. "I felt really good at that point," he said.

The coach lauded the win against Lebanon Valley, a projected top contender in the Middle Atlantic Conference, as giving a clear picture of where the team stood. It's something you can't really gauge in the preseason. And there's a sense of relief if a team starts the season off well, taking two steps forward instead of two back.

"You've got to watch your team develop its mentality," Streeter said. "If they respond in crisis situations or in difficult situations and play well early, that's always encouraging. It makes it a whole lot easier, mentally, on you. It takes that weight off your shoulders about whether these guys are going to respond. They really did."

Tigers keep their bite

Hampden-Sydney finished three quarters with a 45-7 lead over Averett before ending the matchup 45-30 after the Cougars mounted a comeback. Saturday seems to demonstrate how much of a force the Tigers will this year be even without the likes of Corey Sedlar or Andrew Sellers. The defense remains tough for the third year in a row, and that's complemented by an aggressive offense. Tigers quarterback Travis Lane threw for 348 yards and four touchdowns as the team logged its 500th victory since its first season in 1892 and did so against a team that has been touted as a contender for the USA South title.

Bears roar loudly

Defense shone bright for Ursinus as the Bears beat last year's Cinderella playoff team, Albright, 21-13. Ursinus notched seven tackles for losses and three interceptions, two of which were by freshman defensive back Chris Roundtree. Roundtree also paced the team with four pass breakups. The Bears' offense wasn't too shabby either, with senior Justin Decristofaro connecting for 248 passing yards and two touchdowns. The quarterback also led the team in rushing yards. The Ursinus win was among many for the Centennial, which lost just one game to a nonconference opponent in Week 1.

New men under center

Two teams had to play Saturday without their quarterbacks: Maryville senior Tim Conner was confirmed to be out for the season with a shoulder injury prior to the start of the Scots' 54-3 loss to Huntingdon. Marcus Fitzsimmons, a Kickoff writer for D3football.com, has some background on just what Maryville is missing in a story for The Daily Times. In Virginia, Wesley senior Shane McSweeny went down in the team's first drive of the game against Christopher Newport and did not return. Backup signal-caller Justin Sottilare took over and threw for three scores in the No. 3-ranked Wolverines' 34-6 win. One of those went to sophomore tailback Brandon Wright, who found the end zone three times in the first 23 minutes of play.

Greyhounds get some legs

In a game I highlighted in Triple Take on Thursday morning, Moravian overcame its 2009 woes and toppled Centennial newcomer Susquehanna 12-6. The Greyhounds took advantage of their two running-back set of Rocco Del Priore and Joe Tegan to command the clock and muscle out 39 carries between the two. Susquehanna is coming off a playoff run as its former conference's defending champ, but it also has lost a handful of All-Conference players since then.

The blitz package

A freshman put the only points on the board in the McDaniel-Juniata game. On his second field goal attempt of the day, Bill Castor put a 27-yarder through the uprights to help the Green Terror to a 3-0 conference victory.

Salisbury meted out revenge for its loss to N.C. Wesleyan last season by beating the Battling Bishops 13-7 on Saturday. Randall Smedley contributed 105 yards and a touchdown to the Gulls' 248 ground yards, while NCWC found success through the air with 297 yards.

Greensboro came away with a 23-13 victory over cross-town rival Guilford in the Souper Bowl. The matchup, which incorporates a canned-food drive, saw the Pride rack up the bulk of its yards with its passing game. More pride for the Pride? They notched the USA South's only win of the weekend.

On the road again

It's not football season without going to the gridiron in person and seeing how the mid-Atlantic teams stack up. So that's just what I'm going to do! This Saturday I'll be in central Virginia seeing N.C. Wesleyan on the road against Hampden-Sydney. And by this time next week, you'll hopefully be learning about one of the key components of H-SC's stout defense.

Contact me

I would be happy to hear from anyone who has questions or feedback regarding the Around the Mid-Atlantic column or Division III football in general. Please write to me at ryan.tipps@d3sports.com. I'm sure that I missed some highlights in the region. I invite you to talk about players and performances on the message board's Around the Mid-Atlantic thread. Additionally, if there is an idea you'd like to see me write about, post it there or email me.

Andrew Lovell

Andrew Lovell is a writer based in Connecticut and a former online news editor for ESPN.com, as well as a former sports staff writer/editor for the New Britain Herald (Conn.). He has written feature stories for ESPN.com, currently contributes fantasy football content to RotoBaller.com, and has been a regular contributor to D3sports.com sites since 2007. Andrew has also written for a number of daily newspapers in New York, including the Poughkeepsie Journal, Ithaca Journal and Auburn Citizen. He graduated from Ithaca College in 2008 with B.A. in Sport Media and a minor in writing.

2012-2015 columnist: Adam Turer
2007-2011 columnist: Ryan Tipps
2003-2006: Pat Cummings
2000: Keith McMillan
1999: Pat Coleman

Previous Columns

November 14, 2017
A familiar destination, an unfamiliar path
Johns Hopkins is back in the playoffs, but did not arrive via the program's usual Centennial...
November 8, 2017
Eyes on the prize
Washington and Lee has overcome unexpected adversity this season. The Generals enter Week 11 as the...
November 1, 2017
River Hawks receiver ready to run again
Tommy Bluj's final season was derailed by an injury, but he's determined to come back and play...
October 25, 2017
A grand opening
Franklin and Marshall played its first game at the new Shadek Stadium and the Diplomats' new home...
October 18, 2017
Hawks enjoying the adventure
Huntingdon has not followed a typical formula for success, but the Hawks have weathered early ups...
October 11, 2017
Shenandoah surpassing expectations
Underrated in the ODAC's preseason poll, the Hornets are playing with a chip on their shoulders and...
October 4, 2017
Here come the Bears
Ursinus finds itself in the driver's seat of the Centennial Conference. Now, the Bears must learn...
September 27, 2017
Be a man
The Cougars came so close to getting over the hump in Year Three under Cleive Adams. In Year Four,...
September 20, 2017
The little picture is the big thing
Mike Clark has taken Bridgewater to Division III's biggest stage, but these days he is focused on...
September 13, 2017
Starting from scratch
In their first year in Division III and with a new head coach, the Tornados are experiencing growing...
September 7, 2017
Business as usual for Blue Jays
Despite trailing on the road, Johns Hopkins remained cool and collected. The Blue Jays' come-from-be...
November 15, 2016
A proper send-off
Randolph-Macon's senior class is special. It's not just what they've accomplished on the field,...
November 9, 2016
Deja Mules
Cannonball! Muhlenberg hopes to make a big enough splash against Moravian to earn one of the six...
November 1, 2016
Uncharted territory
Shenandoah is led by a record-setting running back who can do it all and a record-setting quarterbac...
 • More Division III football news releases

Other Columnists