September 03, 2011 (17 schools)
AlbrightAugsburgAugustanaCarthageCatholicEarlhamFrostburg StateGallaudetNewport NewsNorth Carolina WesleyanRockfordRose-HulmanSalisburySimpsonUnionUW-Stevens PointUW-Stout September 10, 2011 (11 schools)
AverettCatholicFrostburg StateGallaudetMary Hardin-BaylorSalisburySimpsonSt. ScholasticaUW-Stevens PointUW-WhitewaterWesley September 17, 2011 (12 schools)
Carnegie MellonCatholicFrostburg StateGallaudetHobartKalamazooNorth Carolina WesleyanRose-HulmanUW-StoutUW-WhitewaterWashington and LeeWesley September 24, 2011 (13 schools)
AugustanaCarthageCatholicGallaudetHobartHuntingdonNewport NewsNorth Carolina WesleyanSalisburyUW-StoutUW-WhitewaterWashington and LeeWidener October 01, 2011 (4 schools)
EarlhamHuntingdonNewport NewsWesley October 08, 2011 (4 schools)
HuntingdonNewport NewsNewport NewsSalisbury October 15, 2011 (3 schools)
HuntingdonLaGrangeSalisbury October 22, 2011 (5 schools)
Frostburg StateHuntingdonLaGrangeSalisburyUnion October 29, 2011 (3 schools)
Frostburg StateHuntingdonTrinity (Texas) November 05, 2011 (3 schools)
Newport NewsSalisburyWesley November 12, 2011 (3 schools)
HuntingdonKalamazooLaGrange 