Otterbein vs. Muskingum University at Muskingum University
10/12/2013 at 1:30 PM
Otterbein
12
Muskingum
10
Scoring 1 2 3 4 Final
Otterbein (3-2) 0 6 6 0 12
Muskingum (1-4) 0 3 0 7 10
Muskingum University | McConagha Stadium
Quarters: 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th
1st
1st and 10 at OTT35 Muskingum wins coin toss and defers to 2nd half
1st and 10 at OTT35 MUSK ball on MUSK35.
  Caleb Carpenter kickoff 61 yards to the OTT04, S. Carpenter return 21 yards to the OTT25 (Tyler Lancaster).
Otterbein at 15:00
1st and 10 at OTT25 Ben Sizemore pass complete to Jeremy McCoy for 17 yards to the OTT42 (Darell Jones).
1st and 10 at OTT42 Drew Ervin rush for loss of 2 yards to the OTT40 (Erik Hall; Luke Weber).
2nd and 12 at OTT40 Ben Sizemore pass complete to Jeremy McCoy for 10 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds.
3rd and 2 at OTT50 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to S. Carpenter.
4th and 2 at OTT50 Jordan Keaton punt 42 yards to the MUSK08, fair catch by Alex Dickey.
4 plays, 25 yards, 01:51 elapsed
Muskingum at 13:09
1st and 10 at MUSK08 Muskingum University drive start at 13:09.
1st and 10 at MUSK08 Shane Dotson rush for loss of 1 yard to the MUSK07 (Austin Jones).
2nd and 11 at MUSK07 Shane Dotson rush for 2 yards to the MUSK09 (Eric Mitchell; Zack Grieves).
3rd and 9 at MUSK09 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington, PENALTY OTT pass interference 15 yards to the MUSK24, NO PLAY.
1st and 10 at MUSK24 Shane Dotson rush for 2 yards to the MUSK26 (Austin Jones).
2nd and 8 at MUSK26 Cody Williams pass incomplete to Marvin Morris, PENALTY MUSK sideline interference declined.
2nd and 8 at MUSK26 Cody Williams pass complete to Shane Dotson for 8 yards to the MUSK34 (Will Brett; Ty Compton).
1st and 10 at MUSK34 Cody Williams rush for 5 yards to the MUSK39 (Patrick Coleman; Jaylin Kennedy).
2nd and 5 at MUSK39 Cody Williams rush for 4 yards to the MUSK43 (Pat Seesholtz).
3rd and 1 at MUSK43 Cody Williams rush for 2 yards to the MUSK45 (Patrick Coleman; Zack Grieves).
1st and 10 at MUSK45 Alex Dickey rush for loss of 1 yard to the MUSK44 (Eric Mitchell).
2nd and 11 at MUSK44 Cody Williams pass incomplete to David Carroll.
3rd and 11 at MUSK44 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington, PENALTY OTT pass interference 15 yards to the OTT41, NO PLAY.
1st and 10 at OTT41 PENALTY MUSK false start 5 yards to the OTT46.
1st and 15 at OTT46 Cody Williams pass complete to Alex Dickey for 3 yards to the OTT43 (Jaylin Kennedy).
2nd and 12 at OTT43 Cody Williams pass complete to Marvin Morris for 23 yards to the OTT20, fumble forced by Ty Compton, fumble by ? recovered by OTT Jordan Bonifas at OTT16.
12 plays, 76 yards, 05:41 elapsed
Otterbein at 07:28
1st and 10 at OTT16 Otterbein drive start at 07:28.
1st and 10 at OTT16 Drew Ervin rush for 2 yards to the OTT18 (S.Vinson,Jr.).
2nd and 8 at OTT18 Ben Sizemore sacked for loss of 4 yards to the OTT14 (Nick Beany).
3rd and 12 at OTT14 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to S. Carpenter.
4th and 12 at OTT14 Jordan Keaton punt 35 yards to the OTT49, Alex Dickey return 7 yards to the OTT42 (John Pyles; Eric Mitchell).
3 plays, -2 yards, 01:56 elapsed
Muskingum at 05:32
1st and 10 at OTT42 Muskingum University drive start at 05:32.
1st and 10 at OTT42 Cody Williams rush for loss of 1 yard to the OTT43 (Austin Jones).
2nd and 11 at OTT43 Cody Williams pass incomplete to Wes Rataiczak (Austin Jones).
3rd and 11 at OTT43 Cody Williams sacked for loss of 4 yards to the OTT47 (Eric Mitchell).
4th and 15 at OTT47 Samuel Green punt 34 yards to the OTT13, Connor Lucas return 2 yards to the OTT15 (Tristan Heath; Jordan Smith).
3 plays, -5 yards, 01:25 elapsed
Otterbein at 04:07
1st and 10 at OTT15 Otterbein drive start at 04:07.
1st and 10 at OTT15 Ben Sizemore rush for 4 yards to the OTT19 (Damond Goggins).
2nd and 6 at OTT19 Derik Rudolph rush for 1 yard to the OTT20 (Damond Goggins).
3rd and 5 at OTT20 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to S. Carpenter.
4th and 5 at OTT20 Ryan Thombs punt 40 yards to the MUSK40, out-of-bounds.
3 plays, 5 yards, 01:34 elapsed
Muskingum at 02:33
1st and 10 at MUSK40 Muskingum University drive start at 02:33.
1st and 10 at MUSK40 Melvin Smith rush for 4 yards to the MUSK44 (Eric Mitchell).
2nd and 6 at MUSK44 Cody Williams rush for no gain to the MUSK44 (Zack Grieves; Eric Mitchell).
3rd and 6 at MUSK44 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington.
4th and 6 at MUSK44 Samuel Green punt 36 yards to the OTT20, fair catch by Connor Lucas.
3 plays, 4 yards, 01:17 elapsed
Otterbein at 01:16
1st and 10 at OTT20 Otterbein drive start at 01:16.
1st and 10 at OTT20 Ben Sizemore pass complete to Joey Batey for 5 yards to the OTT25 (Mason Bates; D.Williams).
2nd and 5 at OTT25 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to Jeremy McCoy.
3rd and 5 at OTT25 Ben Sizemore pass complete to Jeremy McCoy for 7 yards to the OTT32 (D.Williams).
back to top
2nd
1st and 10 at OTT32 Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00.
1st and 10 at OTT32 Drew Ervin rush for 1 yard to the OTT33 (Damond Goggins).
2nd and 9 at OTT33 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to Joey Batey (Mason Bates).
3rd and 9 at OTT33 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to Bryson Wray.
4th and 9 at OTT33 Jordan Keaton punt 57 yards to the MUSK10, out-of-bounds.
6 plays, 13 yards, 02:19 elapsed
Muskingum at 13:57
1st and 10 at MUSK10 Muskingum University drive start at 13:57.
1st and 10 at MUSK10 Melvin Smith rush for 5 yards to the MUSK15 (Austin Jones; Tyler Green).
2nd and 5 at MUSK15 Melvin Smith rush for 2 yards to the MUSK17 (Austin Jones; Eric Mitchell).
3rd and 3 at MUSK17 Melvin Smith rush for 7 yards to the MUSK24 (Wes McKeever; Austin Jones).
1st and 10 at MUSK24 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington.
2nd and 10 at MUSK24 Melvin Smith rush for 3 yards to the MUSK27 (Austin Jones).
3rd and 7 at MUSK27 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington.
4th and 7 at MUSK27 Samuel Green punt 47 yards to the OTT26, Connor Lucas return 7 yards to the OTT33 (Jordan Smith; Ethan Jones).
6 plays, 17 yards, 03:00 elapsed
Otterbein at 10:57
1st and 10 at OTT33 Otterbein drive start at 10:57.
1st and 10 at OTT33 Ben Sizemore sacked for loss of 1 yard to the OTT32 (Alex Sullivan; Jordan Lee).
2nd and 11 at OTT32 Ben Sizemore pass complete to S. Carpenter for 8 yards to the OTT40, out-of-bounds (Damond Goggins).
3rd and 3 at OTT40 Ben Sizemore pass complete to Jeremy McCoy for 6 yards to the OTT46 (D.Williams; Erik Hall).
1st and 10 at OTT46 Ben Sizemore pass complete to S. Carpenter for 54 yards to the MUSK00, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:59.
  Alana Gaither kick attempt failed.
4 plays, 67 yards, 01:58 elapsed
  Jordan Bonifas kickoff 60 yards to the MUSK10, Alex Dickey return 13 yards to the MUSK23 (Preston Pearson).
Muskingum at 08:53
1st and 10 at MUSK23 Muskingum University drive start at 08:53.
1st and 10 at MUSK23 Shane Dotson rush for no gain to the MUSK23 (Wes McKeever).
2nd and 10 at MUSK23 Shane Dotson rush for 12 yards to the MUSK35, out-of-bounds (Austin Jones).
1st and 10 at MUSK35 Cody Williams rush for 2 yards to the MUSK37 (Zack Grieves; Austin Jones).
2nd and 8 at MUSK37 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington.
3rd and 8 at MUSK37 PENALTY MUSK delay of game 5 yards to the MUSK32.
3rd and 13 at MUSK32 Cody Williams pass complete to Shane Dotson for loss of 3 yards to the MUSK29 (Ty Compton; Austin Jones), PENALTY MUSK illegal formation declined.
3rd and 16 at MUSK29 Samuel Green punt 51 yards to the OTT20, Connor Lucas return 7 yards to the OTT27 (Jordan Smith; Tristan Heath).
5 plays, 6 yards, 02:20 elapsed
Otterbein at 06:33
1st and 10 at OTT27 Otterbein drive start at 06:33.
1st and 10 at OTT27 Drew Ervin rush for 7 yards to the OTT34 (D.Williams).
2nd and 3 at OTT34 Ben Sizemore pass complete to S. Carpenter for 5 yards to the OTT39 (Damond Goggins).
1st and 10 at OTT39 PENALTY OTT personal foul 15 yards to the OTT24.
1st and 25 at OTT24 1st and 10.
1st and 10 at OTT24 Ben Sizemore rush for 3 yards to the OTT27 (Damond Goggins).
2nd and 7 at OTT27 Ben Sizemore rush for 5 yards to the OTT32 (S.Vinson,Jr.).
3rd and 2 at OTT32 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to Jeremy McCoy.
4th and 2 at OTT32 Jordan Keaton punt 33 yards to the MUSK35, fair catch by Alex Dickey.
5 plays, 5 yards, 02:37 elapsed
Muskingum at 03:56
1st and 10 at MUSK35 Muskingum University drive start at 03:56.
1st and 10 at MUSK35 Cody Williams rush for 15 yards to the 50 yardline (Eric Mitchell; Preston Pearson).
1st and 10 at MUSK50 Cody Williams pass complete to Alex Dickey for 11 yards to the OTT39, out-of-bounds (Ryan Moore).
1st and 10 at OTT39 Cody Williams rush for loss of 1 yard to the OTT40, fumble forced by Patrick Coleman, fumble by ? recovered by MUSK Denny Ardman at OTT38.
2nd and 9 at OTT38 Cody Williams pass complete to Marvin Morris for 4 yards to the OTT34 (Alex Cameron).
3rd and 5 at OTT34 Cody Williams pass complete to J.Washington for 13 yards to the OTT21 (Alex Cameron).
1st and 10 at OTT21 Alex Dickey rush for 3 yards to the OTT18 (Eric Mitchell), PENALTY MUSK holding 13 yards to the OTT31, NO PLAY.
1st and 20 at OTT31 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington.
2nd and 20 at OTT31 Cody Williams sacked for loss of 4 yards to the OTT35 (Patrick Coleman), PENALTY MUSK illegal block declined.
2nd and 24 at OTT35 Cody Williams pass complete to Wes Rataiczak for 13 yards to the OTT22 (Alex Cameron).
3rd and 11 at OTT22 Caleb Carpenter field goal attempt from 39 GOOD, clock 00:38.
  Caleb Carpenter kickoff 67 yards to the OTT03, S. Carpenter return 22 yards to the OTT25 (Alex Adams).
Otterbein at 00:29
9 plays, 43 yards, 03:18 elapsed
1st and 10 at OTT25 Otterbein drive start at 00:29.
1st and 10 at OTT25 Team rush for loss of 1 yard to the OTT24.
2nd and 11 at OTT24 End of half, clock 00:00.
back to top
3rd
1st and 11 at OTT24 Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, OTT ball on OTT35.
1 plays, -1 yards, 00:29 elapsed
  Jordan Bonifas kickoff 61 yards to the MUSK04, Alex Dickey return 14 yards to the MUSK18 (Tony Foreman).
Muskingum at 14:53
1st and 10 at MUSK18 Muskingum University drive start at 14:53.
1st and 10 at MUSK18 Cody Williams pass complete to Shane Dotson for 2 yards to the MUSK20 (Austin Jones).
2nd and 8 at MUSK20 Cody Williams pass complete to David Carroll for 5 yards to the MUSK25 (Ty Compton).
3rd and 3 at MUSK25 Cody Williams pass complete to J.Washington for 6 yards to the MUSK31, out-of-bounds (Alex Cameron).
1st and 10 at MUSK31 Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the MUSK35 (Wes McKeever).
2nd and 6 at MUSK35 Alex Dickey rush for 12 yards to the MUSK47 (Will Brett).
1st and 10 at MUSK47 Cody Williams rush for 6 yards to the OTT47 (Z. Guillozet).
2nd and 4 at OTT47 Cody Williams pass complete to Bradon Hardy for 16 yards to the OTT31 (Alex Cameron).
1st and 10 at OTT31 Alex Dickey rush for no gain to the OTT31 (E. Bergenstein; Eric Mitchell).
2nd and 10 at OTT31 Cody Williams pass complete to Marvin Morris for 5 yards to the OTT26, out-of-bounds.
3rd and 5 at OTT26 Cody Williams rush for 9 yards to the OTT17 (Z. Guillozet).
1st and 10 at OTT17 Cody Williams rush for no gain to the OTT17 (Zack Grieves).
2nd and 10 at OTT17 Cody Williams pass intercepted by Jordan Bonifas at the OTT00, Jordan Bonifas return 0 yards to the OTT00, touchback.
12 plays, 65 yards, 06:11 elapsed
Otterbein at 08:42
1st and 10 at OTT20 Otterbein drive start at 08:42.
1st and 10 at OTT20 Drew Ervin rush for 1 yard to the OTT21 (Damond Goggins).
2nd and 9 at OTT21 Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to S. Carpenter, PENALTY MUSK roughing the passer 15 yards to the OTT36.
1st and 10 at OTT36 Drew Ervin rush for 3 yards to the OTT39 (Ethan Jones).
2nd and 7 at OTT39 Ben Sizemore rush for 7 yards to the OTT46 (Damond Goggins; Erik Hall).
1st and 10 at OTT46 Drew Ervin rush for 4 yards to the 50 yardline (Damond Goggins).
2nd and 6 at OTT50 Ben Sizemore pass complete to S. Carpenter for 7 yards to the MUSK43 (Hank Smith).
1st and 10 at MUSK43 Ben Sizemore pass complete to Jeremy McCoy for 15 yards to the MUSK28 (D.Williams).
1st and 10 at MUSK28 Drew Ervin rush for 2 yards to the MUSK26 (Tyler Lancaster).
2nd and 8 at MUSK26 Ben Sizemore pass complete to S. Carpenter for 26 yards to the MUSK00, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:09.
  Alana Gaither kick attempt failed.
9 plays, 80 yards, 04:33 elapsed
  Jordan Bonifas kickoff 68 yards to the MUSK02, Alex Dickey return 14 yards to the MUSK16 (T.J. Washington).
Muskingum at 04:01
1st and 10 at MUSK16 Muskingum University drive start at 04:01.
1st and 10 at MUSK16 Shane Dotson rush for 7 yards to the MUSK23 (Zack Grieves).
2nd and 3 at MUSK23 Cody Williams pass complete to J.Washington for 37 yards to the OTT40, out-of-bounds (Jaylin Kennedy).
1st and 10 at OTT40 Cody Williams pass complete to J.Washington for 15 yards to the OTT25 (Alex Cameron; Ryan Moore).
1st and 10 at OTT25 Shane Dotson rush for 9 yards to the OTT16, out-of-bounds (Jaylin Kennedy).
2nd and 1 at OTT16 Cody Williams rush for loss of 4 yards to the OTT20, fumble by ? recovered by MUSK Cody Williams at OTT20.
3rd and 5 at OTT20 Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the OTT16 (Ryan Moore).
4th and 1 at OTT16 Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the OTT12 (Tyler Green).
1st and 10 at OTT12 Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the OTT08 (Zack Grieves).
2nd and Goal at OTT08 Melvin Smith rush for 4 yards to the OTT04 (Eric Mitchell).
back to top
4th
3rd and Goal at OTT04 Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00.
3rd and Goal at OTT04 Melvin Smith rush for 3 yards to the OTT01 (Wes McKeever).
1st and Goal at OTT01 Melvin Smith rush for no gain to the OTT01 (M. Greenwell).
2nd and Goal at OTT01 Melvin Smith rush for 1 yard to the OTT00, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:49.
  Caleb Carpenter kick attempt good.
12 plays, 84 yards, 05:12 elapsed
  Caleb Carpenter kickoff 69 yards to the OTT01, S. Carpenter return 18 yards to the OTT19 (Zach Barry).
Otterbein at 13:41
1st and 10 at OTT19 Otterbein drive start at 13:41.
1st and 10 at OTT19 Ben Sizemore pass complete to S. Carpenter for 15 yards to the OTT34 (Hank Smith).
1st and 10 at OTT34 Ben Sizemore rush for no gain to the OTT34 (Evan Wiggall; Jordan Lee).
2nd and 10 at OTT34 Ben Sizemore rush for 2 yards to the OTT36 (Alex Sullivan).
3rd and 8 at OTT36 Ben Sizemore pass complete to Jeremy McCoy for 30 yards to the MUSK34 (Ethan Jones).
1st and 10 at MUSK34 Tyler Hammond rush for 4 yards to the MUSK30 (Damond Goggins).
2nd and 6 at MUSK30 Tyler Hammond rush for 7 yards to the MUSK23, out-of-bounds (Damond Goggins).
1st and 10 at MUSK23 Tyler Hammond rush for no gain to the MUSK23 (S.Vinson,Jr.).
2nd and 10 at MUSK23 Ben Sizemore sacked for loss of 3 yards to the MUSK26 (Damond Goggins).
3rd and 13 at MUSK26 Ben Sizemore sacked for loss of 2 yards to the MUSK28 (Jordan Lee; Nick Beany).
4th and 15 at MUSK28 Timeout Otterbein, clock 07:33.
4th and 15 at MUSK28 Ben Sizemore rush for 12 yards to the MUSK16 (Damond Goggins).
10 plays, 65 yards, 06:16 elapsed
Muskingum at 07:25
1st and 10 at MUSK16 Muskingum University drive start at 07:25.
1st and 10 at MUSK16 Shane Dotson rush for 3 yards to the MUSK19 (Jaylin Kennedy).
2nd and 7 at MUSK19 Cody Williams pass incomplete to Wes Rataiczak (Jordan Bonifas).
3rd and 7 at MUSK19 Cody Williams pass complete to J.Washington for 16 yards to the MUSK35 (Ryan Moore).
1st and 10 at MUSK35 Shane Dotson rush for 11 yards to the MUSK46 (Ty Compton).
1st and 10 at MUSK46 Melvin Smith rush for 6 yards to the OTT48, out-of-bounds (Preston Pearson).
2nd and 4 at OTT48 Cody Williams rush for 1 yard to the OTT47 (Preston Pearson; Zack Grieves).
3rd and 3 at OTT47 Cody Williams rush for 7 yards to the OTT40 (Will Brett).
1st and 10 at OTT40 Cody Williams pass complete to Melvin Smith for no gain to the OTT40 (Jordan Bonifas).
2nd and 10 at OTT40 Melvin Smith rush for 5 yards to the OTT35 (Wes McKeever).
3rd and 5 at OTT35 Cody Williams pass complete to Wes Rataiczak for 5 yards to the OTT30, fumble forced by Austin Jones, fumble by ? recovered by MUSK Sam Lucas at OTT30.
1st and 10 at OTT30 PENALTY MUSK false start 5 yards to the OTT35.
1st and 15 at OTT35 Cody Williams pass incomplete to J.Washington.
2nd and 15 at OTT35 Cody Williams pass incomplete to N.Poling.
3rd and 15 at OTT35 Cody Williams pass complete to Wes Rataiczak for 11 yards to the OTT24 (Jordan Bonifas).
4th and 4 at OTT24 Timeout Otterbein, clock 01:15.
4th and 4 at OTT24 Caleb Carpenter field goal attempt from 41 MISSED, clock 01:08.
14 plays, 60 yards, 06:17 elapsed
Otterbein at 01:08
1st and 10 at OTT24 Otterbein drive start at 01:08.
1st and 10 at OTT24 Drew Ervin rush for 4 yards to the OTT28 (Damond Goggins).
2nd and 6 at OTT28 Timeout Muskingum University, clock 01:03.
2nd and 6 at OTT28 Drew Ervin rush for loss of 1 yard to the OTT27 (Erik Hall).
3rd and 7 at OTT27 Timeout Muskingum University, clock 00:58.
3rd and 7 at OTT27 Ben Sizemore rush for 1 yard to the OTT28 (Erik Hall).
4th and 6 at OTT28 Jordan Keaton punt 42 yards to the MUSK30, downed, PENALTY OTT false start 47 yards to the OTT23, NO PLAY.
4th and 11 at OTT23 Jordan Keaton punt 27 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds.
3 plays, -1 yards, 00:33 elapsed
Muskingum at 00:35
1st and 10 at MUSK50 Muskingum University drive start at 00:35.
1st and 10 at MUSK50 Cody Williams pass incomplete to Bradon Hardy.
2nd and 10 at MUSK50 Cody Williams pass incomplete to Marvin Morris.
3rd and 10 at MUSK50 Cody Williams pass complete to Alex Dickey for 11 yards to the OTT39 (Eric Mitchell; Austin Jones).
1st and 10 at OTT39 Cody Williams rush for loss of 1 yard to the OTT40 (Austin Jones).
2nd and 11 at OTT40 End of game, clock 00:00.
back to top
Dec. 13: All times Eastern
Final
at Mount Union 70, Wesley 21
Box Score Recap Photos
Final
at UW-Whitewater 20, Linfield 14
Box Score Recap Photos
Dec. 19: All times Eastern
Final
UW-Whitewater 43, at Mount Union 34
@ Salem, Va.
Box Score Recap Photos
Maintenance in progress.