| Offense |
First Team |
Second Team |
| QB |
Eli Grant, Sr.,
Case Western |
Scott Kirchoff,
Sr., Bethel |
| RB |
David McNeal,
Sr., Kings Point |
Fletcher Ladd,
Sr., Amherst |
| RB |
Tony Sutton,
Jr., Wooster |
Brad Hodapp,
Sr., Wartburg |
| WR |
Walter Hays,
Sr., Howard Payne |
Justin Salton,
Sr., Franklin & Marshall |
| WR |
Blake Elliott,
Sr., St. John's |
Mark Bartosic,
Sr., Susquehanna |
| TE |
Mike Healy, Sr.,
Chicago |
Matt Moskosky,
Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
| OL |
Larry Kinnard,
Sr., Mount Union |
James Hoxworth,
Sr., Wheaton |
| OL |
Matthew Atkins,
Sr., Thomas More |
Jared Carillo,
Sr., Trinity (Conn.) |
| OL |
James Flowers,
Sr., Trinity (Texas) |
Billy Joe Murray,
Sr., Willamette |
| OL |
Charlie Dutra,
Sr., Menlo |
Chris Ahrens,
Sr., UW-La Crosse |
| OL |
Ben Knepper,
Sr., UW-Stout |
Brent Miller,
Sr., Mount Union |
| Defense |
| DL |
Blair Hammer,
Sr., Wabash |
Joe Kersten,
Sr., UW-Stout |
| DL |
Vince King, Sr.,
Wartburg |
Jarrod Smith,
Trinity (Texas) |
| DL |
Joe Indriolo,
Sr., John Carroll |
Antoine Dillard,
Sr., Mount Union |
| DL |
Jeremy Hood,
Sr., St. John's |
Tiko Williams,
Sr., Randolph-Macon |
| LB |
Ron Swearingin,
Sr., Capital |
Casey Carlson,
Sr., Pacific Lutheran |
| LB |
Jermaine Taylor,
Sr., Bridgewater |
Matt O'Bryant,
Sr., Millsaps |
| LB |
Cam McCambrigde,
Sr., St. John's |
Robert Truman,
Sr., Ithaca |
| DB |
Kennard Davis,
Jr., Thiel |
Ron Shiels, Sr.,
Adrian |
| DB |
Greg Koch, Sr.,
Baldwin-Wallace |
Kyle Hausler,
So., Capital |
| DB |
Ray Lions, Sr.,
Linfield |
Michael Drach,
Sr., Wheaton |
| DB |
Alex Hansen,
Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
John Woock, Jr.,
Washington U. |
| Specialists |
| K |
Greg Switaj,
Sr., Springfield |
Chad Wurth, Sr.,
UW-Whitewater |
| P |
Scott Verhalen,
Sr., East Texas Baptist |
Mike Donnenwerth,
Sr., Simpson |
| RET |
Blake Elliott,
Sr., St. John's |
Jeremy Lynch,
Sr., Brockport State |