2005 Preseason All-Americans
| First Team |
Second Team |
|
| Offense |
||
| QB |
Brett Elliott,
Sr., Linfield |
John Port, Sr., Albright |
| RB |
Justin Bryson, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Phil Porta, Jr., Bethel |
| RB |
Mark Robinson,
Jr., St. John Fisher |
Kevin Nelson, Sr., Wesley |
| WR |
Aaron Krepps, Sr., Washington and Jefferson | David Carmon, Jr., Delaware Valley |
| WR |
Casey Allen, Sr., Linfield | Sakeen Wright, Sr., Rowan |
| TE |
Jon Branche, Jr., RPI | Andy Brogan, Sr., Elmhurst |
| OT |
Mike Zeifert, Sr., Augustana | Rick Drushal, Jr., Wooster |
| OG |
Bryan Ramirez, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Paul Williams, Sr., Hampden-Sydney |
| C |
Mike Pfiester, Sr., Olivet | Dwight Donaldson, Sr., Linfield |
| OG |
Joe Scalice, Sr., Ithaca | Mike Leanch, Sr., Muhlenberg |
| OT |
Steven Beecher, Sr., Western Connecticut | Craig Petrus, Sr., Waynesburg |
| Defense |
||
| DE |
Jason Ripke,
Sr., Simpson |
Mike Lewis, Sr., Adrian |
| DT |
Colby Townsend, Jr., Maryville (Tenn.) | Jesse Wells, Sr., Mount Union |
| DT |
Jason Good, Sr., St. John's | Elex Reed, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| DE |
Jason Trusnik, Sr., Ohio Northern | Matt Lawless, Jr., Mt. St. Joseph |
LB |
Lenny Radtke, Sr., North Central | Brenton Brady, Sr., Alfred |
| LB |
Taz Wallace, Jr., Adrian | Joe Motley, Sr., John Carroll |
| LB |
Michael Bryant, Sr., Occidental | Kareem Morse, Sr., Christopher Newport |
| CB |
Brandon Fox, Jr., Carthage | Byron Westbrook, Jr., Salisbury |
| S |
Kyle Hausler, Sr., Capital | Kenneth Halvorson, Sr., UW-La Crosse |
| S |
Adrian Herndon, Sr., Bridgewater (Va.) | Ross Trimmer, Sr., Grove City |
| CB |
Will Galusha, Jr., Hardin-Simmons | Robbie Parry, Sr., Aurora |
| Specialists |
||
| K |
Cameron Collings, Sr., Whitworth | Holt Storrie, So., Texas Lutheran |
| P |
Kevin Soflkiancs, So., Baldwin-Wallace | Chris Kemmerer, Jr., Buena Vista |
| RET |
Eric Esch, Jr., Illinois Wesleyan | Brandon Hazenberg, Sr., Linfield |