|Overall record: 11-1 - Conference: 6-0|
All times Eastern (* Conference; • D-III opponent)
|9/10||vs. Ohio Wesleyan •||W, 39-36|
|9/17||at Bluffton •||W, 42-0|
|9/24||vs. Bethany * •||W, 41-7|
|10/1||at Washington and Jefferson * •||W, 38-35|
|10/8||vs. Grove City * •||W, 30-0|
|10/15||at Waynesburg * •||W, 35-28|
|10/22||at Westminster (Pa.) * •||W, 34-0|
|10/29||vs. Thomas More * •||W, 24-14|
|11/5||vs. Buffalo State •||W, 21-3|
|11/12||at Carnegie Mellon •||W, 50-48|
|11/19||vs. Johns Hopkins||W, 28-3|
|11/26||vs. Bridgewater||L, 24-13|
November 13, 2018 Blume resigns at Thiel After three seasons, Dan Blume is out at Thiel after just five victories. The Tomcats got four of those wins in Blume's first season.
September 27, 2017 Thiel, W&J postponed until Monday A nasty bug is going around the Thiel College campus, and all activities through Sunday have been cancelled. That means that the football game might be played Monday, or might not be played at all.
September 16, 2017 Barca runs for career-best 189 yards in 28-13 PAC win over Bethany Nick Barca ran for a career-best 189 yards Saturday and scored two fourth-quarter touchdowns to lead the Thiel Tomcats to a 28-13 Presidents’ Athletic Conference (PAC) win over the Bethany Bison.
October 29, 2016 Thiel comes back in fourth quarter to defeat Waynesburg, 50-42 GREENVILLE, Pa. – The Thiel Tomcats scored 13 unanswered fourth quarter points Saturday night to earn a 50-42 comeback win over the Waynesburg Yellow Jackets at The Graveyard.
September 17, 2016 Tomcats slug out PAC win over Bison, 57-47 GREENVILLE, Pa. – In one of the highest-scoring games in Thiel College history, the Thiel Tomcats defeated the Bethany Bison 57-47 Saturday at Alumni Stadium in the Presidents’ Athletic Conference (PAC) opener for both teams.
September 10, 2016 Tomcats edged by Bearcats in home opener GREENVILLE, Pa. – The Thiel Tomcats suffered a hard-fought 32-30 loss to the Saint Vincent Bearcats Saturday night in their home opener at Alumni Stadium.