| Pos. |
First team |
| QB |
Greg Micheli, Mount Union |
| RB |
Nate Kmic, Mount Union |
| RB |
Justin Beaver, UW-Whitewater |
| WR |
Pierre Garcon, Norwich-Mount Union |
| WR |
Blake Elliott, St. John's |
| TE |
Michael Allan, Whitworth |
| T |
J.D. Sheldon, Augustana |
| G |
Derek Blanchard, Mount Union |
| C |
Josh Knox, Hardin-Simmons |
| G |
Josh Warner, Brockport State |
| T |
Blaine Westemeyer, Augustana |
Defense |
| DE |
Bryan Robinson, Wesley |
| DT |
Adam Haas, Cortland State |
| DT |
Ryan Kleppe, UW-Whitewater |
| DE |
Jeremy Hood, St. John's |
| LB |
Jerimiah Janssen, St. Norbert |
| LB |
Jerrell Freeman, Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| LB |
Jermaine Taylor, Bridgewater (Va.) |
| CB |
Pete Ittersagen, Wheaton (Ill.) |
| S |
Kyle Hausler, Capital |
| S |
Josh Kubiak, Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| CB |
Clinton Tabb, Rowan |
Special teams |
| RET |
Larry Beavers, Wesley |
| K |
Jeff Schebler, UW-Whitewater |
| P |
Alex Groh, Occidental |
|
|
|
Pos. |
Second team |
| QB |
Brett Elliott, Linfield |
| RB |
R.J. Bowers, Grove City |
| RB |
Chuck Moore, Mount Union |
| WR |
Nate Jackson, Menlo |
| WR |
Cecil Shorts, Mount Union |
| TE |
Jeff Gibbs, Otterbein |
| T |
Brennan Fortune, St. John Fisher |
| G |
Mackenzie Hay, Augustana |
| C |
Eric Safran, Mount Union |
| G |
Adam Hernandez, Hardin-Simmons |
| T |
Jason Lewis, Mount Union |
Defense |
| DE |
Andy Studebaker, Wheaton (Ill.) |
| DT |
Gerard Bryant, St. Lawrence |
| DT |
Brandon Tisdale, Wilmington |
| DE |
Steven Wilson, King's |
| LB |
Adrian Pynenberg, Wabash |
| LB |
Ron Swearingen, Capital |
| LB |
Kyle Follweiler, Wilkes |
| CB |
Tony Beckham, UW-Stout |
| S |
Matt Kostelnik, Mount Union |
| S |
Derrick Williams, Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| CB |
Chris Kern, Mount Union |
Special teams |
| RET |
Pete Ittersagen, Wheaton (Ill.) |
| K |
Carlos Martinez, Buena Vista |
| P |
Kevin Soflkiancs, Baldwin-Wallace |
|
|
|
Pos. |
Third team |
| QB |
Tom Arth, John Carroll |
| RB |
Mark Robinson, St. John Fisher |
| RB |
Tony Sutton, Wooster |
| WR |
Casey Allen, Linfield |
| WR |
Michael Coleman, Widener |
| TE |
Jon Lanouette, Wesley |
| T |
Max Sakellaris, UW-Whitewater |
| G |
Alex Bell, Hobart |
| C |
Josh Ostrue, St. Thomas |
| G |
Adam Grossman, Ithaca |
| T |
Jeff Oliver, Mary Hardin-Baylor |
Defense |
| DE |
Jason Trusnik, Ohio Northern |
| DT |
Vince King, Wartburg |
| DT |
Matt Williamson, Mount Union |
| DE |
Jarrell Chandler, Salisbury |
| LB |
A.J. Raebel, UW-Whitewater |
| LB |
Preston Meyer, Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| LB |
Gene Lang, St. John Fisher |
| CB |
Alex Hansen, Hardin-Simmons |
| S |
Rocky Myers, Wesley |
| S |
Frank Pilato, Washington and Jefferson |
| CB |
Steve Stepnick, St. John Fisher |
Special teams |
| RET |
Blake Elliott, St. John's |
| K |
Mike Clark, Augustana |
| P |
Scott Verhalen, East Texas Baptist |
|
|
|
Pos. |
Fourth team |
| QB |
Chad Johnson, Pacific Lutheran |
| RB |
Tom Arcidiacono, Union |
| RB |
Phil Porta, Bethel |
| WR |
Jack Phelan, Hartwick |
| WR |
Jerheme Urban, Trinity (Texas) |
| TE |
Jon Branche, RPI |
| T |
Ben Knepper, UW-Stout |
| G |
Jon Stavast, Luther |
| C |
Thomas Anderson, Hardin-Simmons |
| G |
Brandon Bennett, Willamette |
| T |
Larry Kinnard, Mount Union |
Defense |
| DE |
Matt Campbell, Mount Union |
| DT |
Pat Ryan, Benedictine |
| DT |
Nick Gunderson, St. John's |
| DE |
Marcus Ball, UW-Stout |
| LB |
Matt O'Bryant, Millsaps |
| LB |
Cam McCambridge, St. John's |
| LB |
Beau LaBore, St. John's |
| CB |
Will Galusha, Hardin-Simmons |
| S |
Aaron Lewis, Carnegie Mellon |
| S |
Brandon Carr, Bethel |
| CB |
Byron Westbrook, Salisbury |
Special teams |
| RET |
Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg |
| K |
Scott Birkhofer, Linfield |
| P |
Cory Ohnesorge, Occidental |
|
Blaine Westemeyer |
Clinton Tabb |
R.J. Bowers |
Matt Kostelnik
|
Michael Coleman |
Alex Hansen |
Byron Westbrook |
|
